Monday, 22 August 2016

George Harrison's music videos

George Harrison Video Collection
By Mike Carrera

A fan recently asked which was the best Harrison “promo clip compilation” and my response was: NONE to date (official or bootleg).

A good effort was the one by the DVD-R bootleg label FAB Productions, who released a 3 disc set many years ago. The downside point is that many videos there, comes from TV broadcasts with station logos, missing slates, low quality on many clips, and missing dozens of versions and adding clips from concerts or TV shows, or even fake fan-created videos.

In 2016, the European bootleg label BFB/Wonderland/Walrus Entertainment was a direct copy of the FAB’s 3 DVD-R collection from 2010, even with the same menus.

So, to date, no bootleg label have released the ULTIMATE compilation.

On the official side, we have three boxes including a few, but not all of Harrison's videos: ‘The Apple Years’, ‘The Dark Horse Years’ and “The Traveling Wilburys Collection”.

The DVD from the Dark Horse Years boxed set was also released as a standalone DVD some time later.
The problem with those videos on the official releases is that the original audio of many of them have been replaced by the commercially remastered versions, replacing the original mixes, and the bootleg labels have copied exactly THAT version  because of the high visual quality. Sometimes, however, the video is also different from the original version and the bootleg makers and some of the fans haven’t noticed it.

This is a humble research of all available Harrison official videos, including the alternate versions and variations, many of them uncirculated or unbootlegged to date, as well a few revelations and stories TOLD and published FOR THE FIRST TIME. Any corrections/mistake reports are so welcome.

YouTube links are illustrative only, not the researched sources. Almost all videos are 4:3 ratio and a few are 16:9 Widescreen, but for some settings reason, my “photo capture” tool copied all in 16:9, simply ignore this.

Mike Carrera

1971


My Sweet Lord (live)

Sadly, no official video for this song was ever filmed, but the live performance from The Concert for Bangladesh on 1 august, 1971, directed by Saul Swimmer was plugged many times over the years on TV channels, the only difference with the film is that the video features a fade out after George says “Thank you..thank you”. The best quality source for this was probably when the film was re-released in 2005 and the clip was shown many times on music channels like MTV and Much Music.
Many bootleg compilations use a "manufactured" video from the UK TV show "Top of the Pops" from 1971, where the dancing troupe Pan's People did a choreography for this song. This very same footage was used on another fake youtube video for "My Sweet Lord (2000)", editing in some footage from the "All Things Must Pass 30th" EPK and, at some point inserting the Pan's People footage. Bootleg labels  have released it over and over but there is NO official video for the re-recorded version as well there is no one for the original. In the Netherlands, another popular TV show from the 60’s and 70’s: TopPop, produced a "video" in 1970 using some photographs taken from the "Let it Be" book plus some other footage, but again, no official Apple video was ever made.
Both clips from the shows "Top of the Pops" and "TopPop" are available.



Another FAKE fan-created video for the song "Give me Love (Give me Peace on Earth)" is available on some bootleg compilations, be aware it's not a real promo video, although it uses very rare 8mm footage. And we have not counted the version from Live in Japan 1991 (included on the official  "The Apple Years" boxed set) as a promo video.


1974


Dark Horse

Promotional video filmed with a brief but live performance (lasting only 1:53) during rehearsals for the 1974 U.S. tour. Available with a countdown "slate"  in good quality among collectors or  low quality at youtube and some bootleg compilations. It was omitted from the official boxed set "The Apple Years".

Video link


Ding Dong, Ding Dong

The video was directed by Harrison and filmed by Nick Knowland at Friar Park, Henley-On-Thames, George’s mansion. For the video he once again wore two Beatle suits: the grey collarless suit and the Sgt Pepper uniform.
The common version available on almost all bootleg compilations comes from the Australian RAGE music TV show from a 90’s rebroadcast (with logo and credits over the image), but  a clean copy is available among collectors.
Video Link

When it was released on the official "Apple Years" boxed set, although restored to best possible visual quality, there is a mistake during the restoration: the first two seconds shows the picture decolorized and at the third second, the image  goes black for a moment; this visual problem has nothing to do with the master copy being damaged or something like that, since the original print that is available or the rebroadcast on RAGE and other TV specials over the years didn’t have this problem, so, if we want the best and complete version, sadly it’s not on the official boxed set.



Video Link


1976


Crackerbox Palace

Filmed at Friar Park, Henley-On-Thames. Directed by Eric Idle (Monthy Python/The Rutles).
Cameos from Monthy Python’s : Eric Idle, Neil Innes, Michael Palin, John Cleese and Graham Chapman, among others; plus Olivia Arias in black lingerie (at 2:23) .
Video Link

True Love
Filmed at Friar Park, Henley-On-Thames, also directed by Eric Idle. For some reason it wasn’t included on the official "The Dark Horse Years" boxed set.
Another video deemed "best" version around is taken from the Australian video show RAGE (with the logo on screen at some point plus the credits of the song), but a CLEAN version with correct color (Rage’s version is saturated, even if it seems better) is available among collectors.



Video Link


This Song (Variation A)
This Song (Variation B)

Directed by George Harrison and Michael Collins for Rosebud Films. Cameos from Ron Wood and Eric Idle (both dressed as women /Monthy Python’s characters), Jim Keltner (future drummer for the Traveling Wilburys) as the Judge, Neil Innes, among others.
Two slightly different versions are available: Variation A shows the credits for "This Song" over the intro while Variation B is clean and can be found in top quality on the "Dark Horse Years" boxed set and standalone DVD, and sadly is the common version that appears on most recent bootleg compilations leaving out the original version which is available in very good quality and also have the outro credits for "Rosebud Films".


Video Link


1979


Blow Away

Directed by Neil Innes (Monthy Python/ The Rutles). Contrary to what’s written in the book "Eight Arms to Hold You" that the film was shot by early March 1979; the promo was in fact filmed by the end of November or early December 1978 and the first master was assembled by the end of 1978 but was put on hold until next year and it seems a "fix" was made since the new slate, mastered on February 21, 1979 says "Final Mix". Still, the audio is the same as the "1978" version, the only noticeable "difference" could be that there is a Warner Bros logo at the intro plus a very quiet "beep" cue which can be heard before the song starts, plus, once again a Warner Bros logo at the end with the 1978 copyright, and the "1979" version does not have the Warner Bros logo intro or finale, but is exactly the same audio mix and video edit.
Another video that was omitted from the official “Dark Horse Years” boxed set.



Video Link


Faster

Filmed between February 4 and April 8, 1979 at the Grand Prix races in Sao Paulo, Brazil;  Kyalami, South Africa; Long Beach, USA and some shots also apparently filmed in Milan, Italy and other unidentified car races. George's chauffeur in the video is Formula 1 driver Jackie Stewart, although it has not been verified if these scenes were filmed in England or in one of those other countries.

Contrary to what’s been reported, this video was not filmed at only one F1 race in Brazil, and also was not broadcast March 20, 1979, since the single wasn't released until July, more car races were filmed in April and some scenes can be seen on the video. It’s not confirmed that George also attended the South African race, but at least there is much footage from that day included on the video.
George was in fact at the Long Beach race, since footage exists and he was also in Brazil from the last days of January and until February 9, visiting Sao Paulo and Rio de Janeiro. Very rare interview footage from an Argentinian reporter was filmed at the beach in Guarujá, Sao Paulo with George and F1 driver,  Emerson Fittipaldi, footage is available. The interview was made in “cooperation” with Emerson who asked George first if he wanted to do a four question interview (which ended with more than 7). The interview is mislabeled in some sites  or even the Argentina TV re-broadcast as from 1977 but in fact it's from early February 1979 since George says there is a song on the new album about car racing and (the new album) "will be available at the end of February" (footage exists also from another interview he did for the  TV show "Fantastico" plus another interview for a musical magazine and tons of pictures of George with fans at the hotel, airport and the Grand Prix).
Video Link

1981


All Those Years Ago

Compiled by Ron Furmanek using Beatle archival footage and pictures. The video is available clean (without any credits over it) and very good quality among collectors

This is the original version, beware of fake videos created by fans saying "official video", which can also be found on YouTube.
Video Link


1985


Save The World (Greenpeace version)

Directed by Ian Weiner and does not feature any George footage but Greenpeace people "at work". This is the re-worked version that George did for the Greenpeace benefit album.
Video Link


1986


Shanghai Surprise #1 Long Version
Shanghai Surprise #2 Short Version

Produced by Handmade Films,  Filmed at Friar Park, Hanley-On-Thames where George and Vicki Brown recorded their vocals and is mixed with scenes from the film.
Long Version has the full (5:20) recording, and the short (4:40) version (included on the ‘Dark Horse Years’ box set) cuts out 40 seconds of music and more scenes from the film but gladly there are no more scenes with George on the missing seconds. Short version is available in amazing quality and long version in only medium to good.


Video Link


1987


Here Comes The Sun (Prince’s Trust)

A performance from the Second Annual Prince’s Trust Concert TV special (the show was filmed June 6, 1987 at Wembley Arena, UK), this clip was broadcast many times on music TV Channels as a separate music video.


Got My Mind Set On You ARCADE VERSION:
#1 (Copyright over the video)
#2 (Without copyright over the video)

Filmed in London, Directed by Willy Smax. Two variants are available, #1 has the copyright credits over the video near the end while version #2 has the copyright credits after the video is finished. This second version (without slates and copyright credits) was also included in top quality on the "Dark Horse Years" boxed set.


Video Link

#3 (Raw Edit A)
#4 (Raw Edit B)
Also available among bootleg and video collectors are two raw edits of the same video: Raw Edit A is SIMILAR but not the same as the released version, it has many different angles and scenes that were removed from the final version, specially a different dance sequence from the ballet ballerina.
Raw Edit B shows only the "band performance" without any of the arcade video, plus there is no ballerina. A few scenes from this version were included as well on the final cut, but same as Raw Edit A, there are many differences with the released version. Here’s a sample of RAW Edit B. The finale on both Raw Edit A and B is completely different as well to the released version, showing George and the band singing in front of the camera.
Video Link


Got My Mind Set On You HAUNTED HOUSE/CHAIR VERSION:
#1 (Edit A- “Dancer tired”- Copyright over the video)
#2 (Edit A- “Dancer tired”- Without copyright over the video)
#3 (Edit B)

A second version filmed in Los Angeles, Directed by Gary Weis. Two different versions plus one variation are available. #1 has the copyright credits over the video near the end while  #2 has the copyright credits after the video is finished. This is the less known version where George’s double, the dancer has a longer sequence after his routine, he jumps into the chair and act tired for a few seconds and later the video returns with the real Harrison. Edit B or  #3 doesn’t have this scene, after the dancer jumps into the chair, we immediately cut to George playing his guitar. This is not the only difference between Edit A and B, there are more scenes of the "haunted house" and the animals singing on Edit B while on Edit A we see more Harrison footage of him, playing his guitar.
Edit B was also included in top quality on the "Dark Horse Years" boxed set and standalone DVD.



Video Link


1988

When We Was Fab

-When We Was Fab #1 (Edit A- Copyright over the video)
-When We Was Fab #2 (Edit A- Without copyright over the video)
-When We Was Fab #3 (Edit B)

Filmed at Greenford Studios, London, mainly on 18 Dec 1987 but some cameos were filmed on different days that December, plus some in January 1988. Directed by Kevin Godley and Lol Creme.
Cameos from many musicians that also participate on the Cloud Nine album on this innovative video for that time include: Ringo Starr (who appears through all the videos); Jeff Lynne and Ray Copper playing the violin; Elton John putting a coin in a cup while he is being  "robbed" by one of George’s hands. During the near final sequence of this video, while George multiples himself and many characters are passing through (12 to be exact), we can identify more stars that played on the LP: Bobby Kok (cello), Gary Wright (piano) who also looks like Jim Horn (sax) (same look and hair of both of them that December), Vicki Brown (backing vocals), Jeff Lynne (again) and behind him, Jim Keltner, although another bearded musician known as "slowhand" is also a candidate and participated as well on the recordings for this LP, but the final scene is really hard to watch and the other characters are also hard to identify, but there are four women and eight men.
Paul Simon (who didn’t play on the record) also appears pushing a fruit cart during the middle of the video.
A man who looks like (the sideburns don’t match with his looks from that year, or before or after, but let’s say it’s him) Neil Aspinall (The Beatles friend/Road manager and Apple manager for many years) also appears in the key point of the video (definitely NOT Julian Lennon or Phil Collins as reported): holding John Lennon’s Imagine LP while George is playing in the back with Ringo on drums and a mysterious Walrus playing the bass, recreating those Fab days "together" again John, Paul, George and Ringo… or something like that!
The  story of "The Walrus Was Paul" is very well known, so we don’t need to get deeper on that. Also, well known is that Paul is NOT playing the bass wearing a walrus suit on this video. George once told as a joke that Paul was indeed in the video under the walrus suit, and years later Paul answer the same question from many interviews (one, his own Club Sandwich magazine) saying that he wasn’t available on that date (he did some studio recordings) and he’s NOT the man under the walrus suit… but the direct question was: "is that you under the Walrus suit on the “FAB” video?", when in fact it should have been: "Did you participate in the "FAB" video?". And the answer would have been: YESSSS! (If Paul’s mood was in a "myth-breaking" mood)

This is another of those "Beatle-Jokes" that we will never get a YES or NO as a direct answer from them, same as the "Paul is Dead" rumor, among others.
Paul was not available during December 1987 because he was busy in the studio and also making some TV promotion in France and Germany for the "All The Best!" collection, but Director Kevin Godley (a friend of both George and Paul who has directed many of his videos over the years, as well as Beatle projects) managed to film him on a different day and year (plus many more cameos and characters were filmed separately as well) and include THAT over the FAB video. To date, no book or web page has published this info but Paul IS in the FAB video! He appears during the "reunion" sequence looking towards "the band", so we can’t see his full face. This scene is so obvious: Paul appears only during the "Walrus" joke and by the time he passes in front of the Walrus, he turns his face against the man in the costume, like watching the Walrus play. Oh, one other thing, his appearance was distorted to complicate things even more, so recognizing him will be harder!. But any fan that knows every "look" (hair, face, way of walk, etc, etc)  of the Fab’s over the years or any girl with a crush on him, will find this task not hard at all. (Another incorrect theory floating around: Paul is NOT the hippie-dressed guy who’s head is out of the frame and with a large beard around 2:40)


Paul’s cameo was filmed the second week of January 1988 (two weeks before the post production of the video was finished on February 3, 1988), while he was doing some sessions for the Flower in the Dirt  LP. This fact can be verified comparing Paul’s length of his hair. It wasn’t that long during the December 1987 promotion but is THIS long (as he appears on the “FAB” video) during the January footage and pictures that exists plus some TV promotion during February. Check the pictures to compare, just to validate the info that, until today, nobody has published.

This was another "Beatle-Joke", a different clue that was planted on purpose and when the fans were looking directly at the man in the walrus suit playing the bass, the REAL McCartney would appear in front of all of us and nobody would notice him!!



Undocumented but Two different Edits plus one variant are available.
 #1 (Edit A) has the copyright credits over the video near the end while  #2 (Edit A) has the copyright credits after the video is finished.  This is the version that is also available on the official "Dark Horse Years" boxed set and standalone DVD (without slates or copyright credits), sadly they didn’t take care about the original audio, with effects like the sound of the van when Ringo arrives, the coin falling, the apple being bitten, the drunk guys, etc,  and were replaced with the remastered audio track.  Bootleg compilations also use THIS version (because of his high quality), so if we want the original version, sadly it’s not on the official box or the recent bootleg compilations.
Video Link


And #3 (Edit B), being the rarest version barely circulated  and features two different sequences against Edit A:
EDIT A: From 2:45 to 2:47 a woman appears from left to right partially covering George. While on EDIT B there is a different scene.
EDIT B: From 2:45 to 2:46 no woman appears and we keep seeing George and from 2:46 to 2:49, a couple of dunk guys appears from left to right partially covering George. Also blocking two seconds where Ringo appears from right to left carrying a piano.
And the second difference between the two edits:
EDIT A: From 2:56 to 2:59  the same scene of the two drunk guys (see Edit B 2:46 to 2:49)  appears but reversed, from right to left, while on EDIT B we have another notable difference.
EDIT B: From 2:57 to 2:59 from right to left , the same drunk guys appears but using a completely different scene.



This is Love

-This is Love #1 (Copyright over the video)
-This is Love #2 (Without copyright over the video)
Directed by Morton Jankel. Filmed while on vacation at his Maui, Hawaii home. Olivia Harrison make a cameo along with his family. Variant #1 has the copyright credits over the video near the end while  #2  is clean and is the same version available on the official "Dark Horse Years" boxed set and standalone DVD.


Video Link


TRAVELING WILBURYS:

Handle With Care

-Handle with Care #1 (1988 Copyright)
-Handle with Care #2 (1989 Copyright)
-Handle with Care #3 (Australian)
-Handle with Care #4 (Cropped)
Filmed in Los Angeles, CA. Variant #1 has the 1988 copyright credits over the video near the end while  #2  is clean but when the video ends there is a 1989 copyright, so, the first version was distributed late 88 and second in early 89, still, both are the same in visual content.


#3 was broadcast in Australia on the RAGE TV show and everything is the same except for the final seconds, from 3:06 to 3:14, where the white truck with the Wilburys logo appears, the speed for this final sequence runs SLOWER, while on the normal version (#1 or #2) the truck moves from right to left faster, on the Australian edit it goes slower and ends before the woman on the bike appears, but the audio track has no differences at all, the same speed, no alterations.

#4 was released on the official Traveling Wilburys Box set, simulating a widescreen version but cropping picture from top and bottom.

Bootleg compilations also use THIS version (because of his high quality), so if we want the original version, sadly it’s not on the official boxed set or the recent bootleg compilations.
Video Link


1989


End of The Line

End of The Line #1 (Edit A -Copyright over the video)
End of The Line #2 (Edit A- Without copyright over the video)
End of The Line #3 (Edit B)
Filmed in Los Angeles, CA shortly after Roy Orbison’s death. Directed by Willy Smax. Again, two different edits and one variation available.
Edit A Variant #1 has the copyright credits over the video near the end while Edit A Variant #2  is clean. Edit B is available on the official Traveling Wilburys boxed set.
And the main difference between Edit A and Edit B is the intro and finale where the train was removed from Edit B, showing footage of the Wilburys instead, plus, Edit B is in widescreen showing even more picture on the sides that is not present on the first edit but again, is also cropped on top and bottom. Still, this was NOT a 4:3 to 16:9 transfer (like "Handle With Care"), since the master video tapes were used and we get different scenes (intro and finale) and full picture on the sides. Bootleg compilations also use THIS version (because of his high quality), so if we want the original version, sadly it’s not on the official box or the recent bootleg compilations.


Video Link


1990


Nobody’s Child

Directed by Derek Hayes for the benefit album Nobody's Child: Romanian Angel Appeal. It does not features the actual Wilburys, but animated cartoons along with footage from orphanages in Romania. This is the only Wilbury video omitted from the official deluxe box from 2007 and 2016, but it’s in circulation complete with slates and in very good quality. The YouTube clip doesn’t reflects any of that! But due to copyright issues, almost all Wilburys videos were removed and only the official channels are active.


Video Link

She's My Baby

-She’s My Baby Version #1
-She’s My Baby Version #2

Directed by David Leland. Two different versions available. The second was released in 2007 on the official Traveling Wilburys boxed set and is 80% distinct from the original version from 1990. It features not only different angles but also scenes from another take(s). This second version is little bit shorter and cuts the final scene of the man "chasing" the Wilburys aboard a car.

Bootleg compilations also use THIS version (because of his high quality), so if we want the original version, sadly it’s not on the official box or the recent bootleg compilations.



Video Link
Video Link


Inside Out

-Inside Out Version #1
-Inside Out Version #2

Once again, two different versions available. The second was released in 2007 on the official Traveling Wilburys boxed set and is 80% distinct from the original version from 1990. It features not only different angles but also scenes from another take or takes. This second version is 23 seconds shorter and the audio mix uses the remastered track, while the original audio version from 1990 has an instrumental/orchestral warm-up intro behind a red curtain and the sound of claps at the end (removed from Version #2).
Bootleg compilations also use THIS second version (because of his high quality), so if we want the original, sadly it’s not in the official boxed set or the recent bootleg compilations.
Also in circulation is some rehearsal footage (mislabeled on ALL the bootleg releases as being "outtakes" or "alternate version" for  the "She’s My Baby" video, which is incorrect) and also behind the scenes and raw footage from the actual shooting.

Video Link


1991


Wilbury Twist

-Wilbury Twist Version #1
-Wilbury Twist Version #2
-Wilbury Twist Version #3

Filmed in Los Angeles, CA. Three different versions available. Version #1 and #2 (the rarest of the two) have a similar format but alternates distinct footage and cameos from special guests:
John Candy, Eric Idle, Cheech Marin (Cheech and Chong), Whoopi Goldberg, Woody Harrelson , Milli Vanilli, Fred Savage (The Wonder Years), among others. Both versions are available in very good quality and clean of logos and credits among collectors. Version 2 is only available on bootleg compilations taken from a music TV channel with logo and credits over the picture.

Version 3 only features John Candy and Eric Idle over the intro using the same footage from Version #1, the other cameos were eliminated, but the rest is a completely new edit using different angles and takes and was released in 2007 on the official Traveling Wilburys box set.

Outtake footage from an unreleased alternate edit (fourth version) that only shows the Wilburys playing also exist.




Video Link


2003


Any Road 

Directed by Simon Hilton and Pamela Esterson using archival footage from the Harrison State, include some very rare and never before seen clips.


Video Link


2004


Taxman (The Dark Horse Years) 

If you search under the official George Harrison YouTube channel,  many of the "Live in Japan" clips extracted from the ‘Dark Horse Years’ box set are labeled as "official video", but only one of the songs from the 1991 Japanese tour was actually released as a "promo clip" for TV airing and it was "Taxman". This clip was sent to promote the release of "The Dark Horse Years" boxed set.



 2006


-Living in the Material World
-Sue Me Sue You Blues (demo)
-Miss O’Dell (alternate version)

Three videos created for the “Living in the Material World” deluxe edition (CD/DVD) re-release in 2006.

2014


-What Is Life 

Directed by Brandon Moore, winner of the Genero.tv contest to create the official video for the song.

Video Link


GEORGE HARRISON  RELATED VIDEOS:

1985


The Singing Rebel’s Band: Freedom (Promo Version)

Directed by Dick Clement for Handmade films, produced by Harrison for the film ‘Water’.
Billy Connolly (vocals), Chris Tummings (vocals), The Singing Rebels Band: George Harrison (guitar, backing vocals), Ringo Starr (drums), Eric Clapton (guitar, backing vocals), Chris Stainton (bass), Ray Cooper (drums), Jon Lord (keyboards), Mike Moran (keyboards), Jenny Bogle and Anastasia Rodriguez (backing vocals).

The actual promo video for this song is available in regular quality and unbootlegged to date and consist of the same "performance" from the film and a mixture of many scenes from the movie, but the audio over the intro is clean and slightly different, when in the film we can see and hear an actor saying "My God it's The Concert for Cascara!" (a parody of ‘The Concert For Bangladesh’). Also, actor Fred Gwynne (Herman from The Munsters) who also appears in the "Water" film, can be seen in this version saying "Gentlemen, we’re in the water business".



- Freedom (Film Version 1)
- Freedom (Film Version 2)

The common version on bootleg compilations over the years is taken directly from the film Version #1. And when it was re-released on DVD in 2010, a new cut was made including some alternate scenes (an exclusive Harrison/Clapton scene for example), we will call that Film Version #2, cut in Widesceen from the original film tapes adding even more picture on the sides that is not available in the original print that let us see a few more Harrison (and many other members of the band, like Clapton) shots. These two versions are not promotional videos, but worth mentioning.
Video Link


1989


Tom Petty: I Won’t Back Down

Directed by David Leland. The backing band consisted of Jeff Lynne on bass, George Harrison on acoustic guitar, Mike Campbell on lead guitar, and Ringo Starr on drums.
Almost replicating the same personnel from the studio recording, except for Ringo who didn’t play, that was Phil Jones.


Video Link


1990


Jeff Lynne: Every Little Thing 

Directed by Meiert Avis. George plays on the studio recording and also sings three times on this song the line "All the secrets that you hide" at 1:33 and also at 2:42 and the shorter line "the secrets that you hide" at 3:24, but that’s not all. Harrison and Tom Petty make surprise cameos in this video, hanging from a rope from 2:36 to 2:58.

Also versions with and without copyright over the picture at the end are available. The version on bootleg compilations  is taken from a TV broadcast with credits over it, but a clean copy with slate circulates among collectors. The way this animated video was created at that time makes it a little harder to see some hidden details, luckily the Harrison cameo is clearer.


Video Link


Jeff Lynne: Lift Me Up                      

The follow up to the "Every Little Thing" video, also directed by Meiert Avis using the same mix with 3D animation. George plays on the song and also makes a brief and almost unnoticeable cameo dressed as a devil at 2:59 and until 3:03. Sadly the version that appears over and over on FAB’s collections and other labels is taken from a VH1 broadcast with logos and the intro slightly cropped. The full video including the slate is available among collectors. The way this animated video was created at that time makes little harder to see some hidden details, including George’s cameo. Hopefully Jeff Lynne will release an official collection of his solo videos in the future to get a better version.



Video Link


1995


Gary Wright: Don’t Try to Own Me

Directed by Michael Schultz, features Harrison doing some backing vocals that were recorded back in 1992. It circulates with slate and final credits among collectors. Outtake footage also exists from this vocal session and some of these scenes were included on the final video.


Video Link


Official videos from other artists. George plays on these tracks but does not make any video cameos.

1973: Cheech And Chong - Basketball Jones

1989: Belinda Carlisle: Leave a light on

1992: Jimmy Nail: Real Love

2001: Jim Capaldi: Anna Julia

George plays guitar on the record but does not appear on the official clip. A FAKE fan-created video using George footage from the "Real Love" video and the "All Things Must Pass 30th" EPK was inserted during his guitar solo and uploaded to YouTube years ago, and many fans thought that THAT was the real promo video, it’s also featured on bootleg compilations, but the actual clip does NOT feature any Harrison footage.

Another Jim Capaldi promo for the song "Oh Lord, Why Lord?" from 1990,  which supposedly features a cameo from Harrison is not in circulation.

Breaking Myths:

1-"My Sweet Lord" from Top of The Pops 1971 (Pans People dancers) is NOT an official video.
2-"My Sweet Lord (2000)" - an official video never existed.
3- There is no official video for "Someplace Else", also included on bootleg compilations. The clip we see on the "Dark Horse Years" boxed set comes from the TV special "Handmade in Hong Kong", - a behind the scenes look at the film.
4- George Harrison does not play on Roy Orbison’s "You Got It", despite some bootleg labels have included the official video for this song on their Beatle/Harrison compilations.

Songs from TV shows, like "The Pirate Song" from Rutland TV, or "This Song" from DISCO German TV, or "Between The Devil and the Deep Blue Sea" from Jools Holland's TV special are not promotional videos, even though you can find them on every bootleg promo collection compilation, the same situation is the full Harrison Prince’s Trust performances and  Dylan’s celebration concert, among others, that’s just a cheap way to fill a "promo compilation" because the makers don’t have enough stuff to compile the ULTIMATE video collection.

30 comments:

winston o´boogie said...

Incorrect. The man looking at the "FAB Band" is no other than Bob Dylan.
You have to research a little harder ;)
Paul wasn't available and did not want to participate anyway.

CCRider said...

Doesn't look like Bob Dylan. AT ALL.

Mary said...

Of course that is Not Bob Dylan!
Open your eyes, do better research and please read, Paul's cameo was filmed weeks later after Ringo and George were together to film their parts. Jerry Chater (the editor)can give you more details! ;)
Dylan's look from 87/88 here:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZpZ1ZtnNfew
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AIjzSrq0UgE
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iiY9d0e_GNI
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jdmu4vkkRO4


Roger Stormo said...

Mike Carrera has sent in this to counter the "Bob Dylan" claim.

Nighthawk said...

I really don't think that looks ANYTHING like Paul.

juan ugalde said...

As a huge beatle fan who can recognize any angle, voice tone or instrument playing for an entire life dedicated to the Fab 4 I can confirm Mike' post. That's TOTALLY Paul McCartney! Not Dylan and no doubt about it. And by the way the walrus on the black Rickenbaker bass its not Paul. Easy to tell.

EL KABBALLERO said...

EVIDENTE QUE ES PAUL. SI HASTA HUELE A PAUL.

Rediffusion said...

I don't see Michael Palin, John Cleese or Graham Chapman in the Crackerbox Palace video.

Queenie Eye said...

Of course he is Paul!!! No doubt about it!! The look and hair are totally Macca. I can recognize him miles away! So many years following him, I learned to identify his beautiful face! ha... Dylan looks really different, he has curly hair and other facial features. So I agree with Mike. HE is Paul... yes he is!

Mary said...

I was trying to find them as well, it's a hard one. Eric appears under a costume and Neil is easy one, he appears as a woman pushing George on his baby carriage, and I think he's also the police/priest character, and during the middle and over the end he appears also dressed with a yellow duck helmet over his head but his face is so clear.
And check this:
https://books.google.com.mx/books?id=Ud9h3kdxQNQC&pg=PA392&lpg=PA392&dq=pantomime+princess+margaret+monty+python&source=bl&ots=6nmu16rDYp&sig=fxqIPWTvWQIKyGvAPi8h1vxKpFY&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwj1gseAjdbOAhVB12MKHZKDCR4Q6AEITDAK#v=onepage&q=pantomime%20princess%20margaret%20monty%20python&f=false

I can't see Mr Cleese either but there is a reference to Pantomime Princess Margaret (that episode is available to watch and it's not a look-a-like doll, it's the real one used by the Phytons! and according to the official biography, Mr Cleese was the man behind ) and also a reference to Chapman's Pythons character according to the movieblog.wordpress.com:
"... as well as appearances by look-alikes from the Pythons’ Pantomime Queen and Graham Chapman’s “This is getting too silly” Colonel."

My note: it's not a look-a-like Pantomine Queen, it's the real costume!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dkLsdQhZsw0

The Major/Colonel character is a reference of Chapman, but searching the credits for the video, all five names of the Montys appear, weird!

From here it mentions John Cleese as well:
http://www.thatericalper.com/2016/05/19/official-promotional-video-for-george-harrisons-crackerbox-palace-originally-released-in-1976/

and according to this page, he's also on the "cast and crew", I don't know if they are under the gnome masks at some point. Since the Phyton/Harrison connection was so close at that time there will be no doubt if all them agreed to do some appearances in disguise.
And there are nine gnome characters when they are dancing and all of them are tall, not the same "little" people characters that are also in different parts of the video (inside George's mansion for example) and only four tall gnomes appear not nine.
I also don't know who is the Dracula/clown or the guys dressed as male nurses?.
https://imvdb.com/video/george-harrison/crackerbox-palace




Unknown said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Unknown said...

**Apparently McCartney had THIS to say in Record Collector, Feb 1995, No.186, p.21:

"George wanted me to be in it but I wasn't available. So I suggested that he put someone else in the walrus and tell everyone that it was me"."

Fred Nerk said...

The RAGE broadcast of comes from a RAGE Beatles Special from 8th December, 2001 (not the 90s). It was in honor of George's (then) recent passing.

George's video played during this special were:

All Things Must Pass - GEORGE HARRISON - Interview & Songs EMI
Ding Dong - GEORGE HARRISON EMI
True Love - GEORGE HARRISON EMI
2:30am Crackerbox Palace - GEORGE HARRISON EMI
This Song - GEORGE HARRISON EMI
Blow Away - GEORGE HARRISON EMI
Faster - GEORGE HARRISON EMI
All Those Years Ago - GEORGE HARRISON Warner
Got My Mind Set On You - GEORGE HARRISON Warner
When We Was Fab - GEORGE HARRISON Warner
This Is Love - GEORGE HARRISON EMI
3:00am Handle Me With Care - TRAVELING WILBURYS Warner
She's My Baby - TRAVELING WILBURYS Warner

http://www.abc.net.au/rage/playlist/archive/2001/20011208.htm

Unknown said...

I think it is really easy to imagine that it is a Paul look-a-like. I'm trying to imagine a scenario where Paul consents to be included in a music video, and then you don't actually see his face. I'm certainly willing to yield if there is documentation that Paul was definitely included in the festivities.. but if we are just talking about what it "looks" like... I'd say they got someone how looks a bit like him from that angle. I mean, we see hair and a cheekbone. That's pretty easy to do a stand-in for. I can see why they would stick a surreal likeness of him in there during the Walrus shot.

I'm perfectly willing to believe otherwise if there is documentation, or actual word from someone who involved. (I certainly don't assume I know better, at all, and I really don't think it looks like Bob.) But why wouldn't we see at least a momentarily clear shot of his face for 2 frames? The video was obviously very carefully assembled... and we see Elton just fine.

Paul himself seems to believe that he was not actually included in the video, but just his likeness. (per earlier post)

Marshall Fish said...

Nice article and interesting info. Here's the link for a web article I wrote on five of George's music videos (I apologize for the shameless plug):

http://hubpages.com/entertainment/The-top-five-music-videos-by-George-Harrison

Fred Nerk said...

The colour saturation on RAGE's "True Love" video was because RAGE showed a very low quality copy of the video on the original broadcast. All copies going around online are sourced from that off-air broadcast recorded onto VHS tape. So you have something that didn't look that good to begin with, captured on a dodgy format.

But a first generation VHS copy (which I have), does look better than the low-res YouTube version that's available at the moment. The video uses a soft focus effect to make it seem more "romantic". This does not work with the old school YouTube compression standard (the video was uploaded in 2008). Which is why it's a muddy looking mess.

Mary said...

There were MANY RAGE TV broadcasts, most of the videos on bootleg come from the 90's broadcast and a few from the 2001. The RAGE 90's broadcast is 4 DVDs, tons of videos from beatles/John/Paul/George and Ringo, not from the 2001, and also there was a July 1987 broadcast also on bootleg DVDR by MCP label, as you can see, many RAGE specials, but all have the LOGOS, the important thing is to get those promos without the logos as described on this research.

Mary said...

Blogger Unknown said...

**Apparently McCartney had THIS to say in Record Collector, Feb 1995, No.186, p.21:

"George wanted me to be in it but I wasn't available. So I suggested that he put someone else in the walrus and tell everyone that it was me"."

23 August 2016 at 01:38

yes, that's also described at this research, Paul wasn't available in December and also described that Paul is not the man in the walrus suit, he's talking about a different character.

wardo said...

I thought it was Dylan in '88, I still think it now.

More to the point, thanks for honing in on Olivia in black lingerie. Yowza!

Unknown said...

Hey Mary, thanks for attempting to clarify. I do understand they are not talking about the guy in the Walrus suit.

What I am saying is, if real footage of Paul McCartney was used in the video, he would have known about it and would have had to agree to it. (Even if it does look remarkably like his hair, cheekbone and walk to the point where a good many people are fooled by it.) I consider his personal recollection to be an excellent source in the matter. He says he was asked, but that he does not appear in the video. Additionally, knowing how these things work, if they had used footage of the real McCartney, we'd be seeing his face as clearly as we do with the others, like we do with Ringo and Elton, etc. There just is no doubt that Paul would be aware of it, and he says he's not in the video. If there is actual contrary evidence to put up against what McCartney remembers about it, other than it looking remarkably like him, I'm definitely open-minded about considering it, I just haven't seen any of that evidence yet.

Debjorgo said...

That MIGHT be Dylan in the Walrus suit. Or maybe it's the Paul look-alike in the walrus costume. (William Campbell's the Walrus?!)

That's a perfect Paul McCartney walking by though.

Debjorgo said...

Unknown - Paul explains why he wasn't in the Walrus suit. He doesn't discuss the cameo walk-by. Not showing his face just adds a little topic for discussion. Measure the mystery.

Unknown said...

The whole discussion is just too silly to continue. Paul doesn't say that he is somewhere in the video and just not in the Walrus suit so you have to look closer to spot him. He has never said that once, ever. We all can believe what we want to believe. I'm just looking for actual evidence.

NP said...

Whoever is in the Walrus suit is 6' 3", Bob is scarely 5'9". Definitely Paul doing the walk by, no question.
Not Neil Aspinall with the LP though.

Mike said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Mike said...



Paul FAB

Queenie Eye said...

Haha... So far there´s no doubt if he is or not Macca. Of course he is... The Mike´s research is deep enough to proof this idea.

Unknown said...

I agree it looks remarkably like his hair, and his cheekbone, and his walk. I never said otherwise. I am looking at a much better quality video than these captures show, and I agree. That looks LIKE McCartney... remarkably.

What I am looking for is not more screen captures, but instead actual evidence. It was said that "Director Kevin Godley...managed to film him on a different day and year...and include THAT over the FAB video." Where does this statement come from, would be more of an answer to my question. Does he state this in an interview? If so, where? I'm happy to believe. But I do insist on some sort of actual evidence.

I'm not even insinuating that anyone here needs to prove it to me. I'm just telling you that I am skeptical until I see evidence beyond screen capture "looks like him" comparisons.

Roger Stormo said...

Dear all,
I think it's about time we abandoned the discussion about whether or not that's Paul McCartney walking by in the "walrus" scene. I think Mike has been privy to the information, either by someone working on the shot that day or someone who knew someone who was involved in the filming. And without revealing his sources, all he can support his information with, are the comparison shots he has provided us with. As this, as Mike says, is now an inside joke among the Beatles themselves (now sadly only Paul and Ringo), no one in the production crew is going to come clean about it, that can only be Paul's own privilege, should he wish to. Either by having been asked specifically about it, or as a revelation in some future documentary. No amount of photographic comparison is going to convince the nay sayers, as the distorted image of the person walking by is anything but conclusive - and probably was done this way on purpose. So instead of discussing this subject further, I suggest we concentrate on Mike's wonderful research about George's promotional films and music videos - he has done a great job here.

I remember that back in the day when there was talk about a soundtrack album to accompany the "Shanghai Surprise" film, there was a Norwegian TV programme which had music in films as it's theme, and they actually showed about a minute of the "Shanghai Surprise" promo. This was before the idea of a soundtrack album was scrapped, due to the commercial failure of the film, and around the same time that a promo 45 with the title track was being sent out to people in the industry. As you know, when the soundtrack album was abandoned, the songs were instead recycled by George to end up on his comeback "Cloud Nine" album, and the full promotional video for "Shanghai Surprise" was not broadcast in public again until years later.

cb70 said...

Isn't it a possibility that they used a photograph of Paul which is why the image of him is distorted to give the static picture the appearance of it 'walking' by?